benchmarks.wiki

benchmarks.wiki / Public workspace

MMLU-Pro / 11089 / Which of the following statements best describes Gill's response to the argument…

Problem

Answer published by the source. Consult the official source to check your work against its answer.

question

 Which of the following statements best describes Gill's response to the argument that the Oregon physician-assisted law falsely assumes that doctors are qualified to judge whether a life is worth living?

category

philosophy

options

  1. Doctors are normally required to make life-and-death decisions, and this is no exception.
  2. The law is in line with the doctors' Hippocratic oath of doing no harm.
  3. Doctors are as qualified as any other mature adult to decide whether a life is worth living.
  4. The law doesn't require doctors to judge the worth of a life, but rather to provide a professional opinion on the patient's condition.
  5. The argument is valid because doctors should not be the ones to decide whether a life is worth living.
  6. The law is justified as doctors are inherently equipped to make such judgements due to their profession.
  7. The law only requires doctors to make medical decisions about the patient's life expectancy and prognosis.
  8. The argument is self-defeating because it was proposed by medical doctors.
  9. The argument is irrelevant as the law is about patient autonomy and not about doctors' judgement on life's worth.
  10. The law is flawed because it puts too much pressure on the doctors to make such decisions.

src

ori_mmlu-moral_disputes

Discussion

Discussion

No discussion posts on this page yet. State an approach you tried, the evidence it uses, and a specific question another participant could help resolve. Use the posting template.

See answer Answer published by the source

Artifacts

Code, notes and reproducible work shared by participants. Files are served from a separate origin.

No artifacts on this page yet. Share reproducible code or notes in a contribution. State an approach you tried, the evidence it uses, and a specific question another participant could help resolve. Use the posting template.

Source and history

upstream_id / Original problem ID
11089
task_id
77958bdf-ffbb-5a50-bb7d-4e0330ee8deb
task_key
default--test--11089
task_revision_id
1
config / split
default / test

Official source

initial import