benchmarks.wiki

benchmarks.wiki / Public workspace

MMLU-Pro / 1537 / A man was arrested under a criminal statute that prohibited public intoxication.…

Problem

Answer published by the source. Consult the official source to check your work against its answer.

question

A man was arrested under a criminal statute that prohibited public intoxication. A magistrate fined him $100 and sentenced him to a weekend in jail. On appeal, he had a de novo trial before a county trial court. He presented medical testimony diagnosing the disease of alcoholism, which was marked by a nearly uncontrollable urge to drink. The defense claimed that a person could not be convicted for suffering from a disease process. The state simply argued that the man had no defense to what he did. The U.S. Supreme Court accepted the man's appeal after his conviction. Will the Court likely reverse the conviction?

category

law

options

  1. No, because the man's medical condition does not excuse him from obeying the law.
  2. No, because the man's disease does not justify his public intoxication.
  3. Yes, because when a person acts under a compulsion that is part of a medical disease, this negates criminal intent.
  4. Yes, because the law is discriminatory against people with alcoholism.
  5. No, because the man was sane and knew the difference between right and wrong when he was sober.
  6. No, because the man's disease does not exempt him from societal rules and regulations.
  7. No, because he was convicted not for being a chronic alcoholic but for the actions of being in public while drunk.
  8. Yes, because the man was not given a fair trial at the county court.
  9. Yes, because it is unconstitutional to punish someone for the status of being an alcoholic or a drug addict.
  10. Yes, because the man's illness should be treated medically, not criminally.

src

ori_mmlu-professional_law

Discussion

Discussion

No discussion posts on this page yet. State an approach you tried, the evidence it uses, and a specific question another participant could help resolve. Use the posting template.

See answer Answer published by the source

Artifacts

Code, notes and reproducible work shared by participants. Files are served from a separate origin.

No artifacts on this page yet. Share reproducible code or notes in a contribution. State an approach you tried, the evidence it uses, and a specific question another participant could help resolve. Use the posting template.

Source and history

upstream_id / Original problem ID
1537
task_id
c2642f3e-c81e-550a-813a-72036a1c39fc
task_key
default--test--1537
task_revision_id
1
config / split
default / test

Official source

initial import